Garlic Mizithra at The Old Spaghetti Factory inspires such fierce loyalty that regulars order it before scanning the menu. This guide covers the full Toronto waterfront menu, kids options, and how the restaurant handles gluten-free requests, all backed by official sources.

4 related posts

Signature Dish: Garlic Mizithra ·
Kids Age Limit: 12 and under ·
Gluten-Free Pasta: Available with upcharge

Quick snapshot

1Confirmed facts
2What’s unclear
  • Exact menu prices are not published online
  • Halal certification status has not been confirmed
  • Specific upcharge amount for gluten-free pasta at Toronto is not listed publicly
3Toronto-specific details
4What comes with the meal
  • Hot bread and minestrone soup or crisp green salad (The Old Spaghetti Factory)
  • Signature spumoni or vanilla ice cream for dessert (The Old Spaghetti Factory)
  • Tea or coffee included with the full meal (TripAdvisor)

The following table consolidates essential details about the Toronto waterfront location for quick reference.

Detail Value
Location Toronto, Ontario (waterfront)
Phone 416-864-9761
Signature Dish Garlic Mizithra
Kids Age Limit 12 and under
Full Meal Includes Bread, soup or salad, entrée, ice cream, beverage
Gluten-Free Status Options available but not certified gluten-free
Chain Origin American chain with Canadian locations
Halal Status Not confirmed

What is the Spaghetti Factory’s most popular dish?

Garlic Mizithra is the dish that keeps diners coming back to The Old Spaghetti Factory. The recipe combines brown butter, Mizithra cheese, and fresh garlic over pasta—a combination that’s simple yet hard to replicate at home. According to TripAdvisor reviews, regulars often order this before even looking at the menu.

Garlic Mizithra details

The Mizithra version ranks as one of the highest-calorie gluten-free options on the menu at approximately 1,120 calories with gluten-free pasta. For those keeping track, the official gluten-friendly menu from The Old Spaghetti Factory lists the following sauce options with calorie counts:

  • Marinara — 490 Cal
  • Rich Meat — 580 Cal
  • Sautéed Mushroom — 600 Cal
  • Clam — 750 Cal
  • Mizithra Cheese & Browned Butter — 1,120 Cal

The high calorie count for the Mizithra comes primarily from the browned butter base, which is poured generously over the pasta.

The upshot

If you’re watching calories, the Marinara sauce (490 Cal) offers the lightest gluten-free option. But if you want the authentic experience, the Mizithra is worth every calorie—it’s what the restaurant is known for.

Other top pasta options

Beyond the signature Garlic Mizithra, other crowd-pleasers include Baked Lasagna and Chicken Parmigiana. These entrees follow the same all-inclusive dining format: bread, soup or salad, and ice cream come with every plate.

The implication: the restaurant bets that simple, high-calorie indulgence wins. For calorie-conscious diners, the Marinara option exists—but the Mizithra remains the reason most people return.

What soup does The Old Spaghetti Factory have?

The restaurant serves minestrone soup as its primary soup offering, and it’s included with every entrée. The official menu from The Old Spaghetti Factory states that every entrée comes with “hot bread, minestrone soup or a crisp green salad.”

Soup included with entrees

There’s no extra charge for the minestrone, and there’s no limit—the restaurant is known for generous, unlimited servings of bread and soup or salad. Diners on TripAdvisor frequently mention this as a standout value proposition for families.

Salad alternatives

If you prefer something cool and crisp, the salad option lets you choose from various dressings. For those on a gluten-free diet, the restaurant notes that “gluten-free salad at The Old Spaghetti Factory can be served without croutons,” according to Find Me Gluten Free.

What are the menu prices at The Old Spaghetti Factory Toronto?

Specific menu prices are not published on the restaurant’s website or available through major review platforms. However, what is clear is the value structure: every entrée comes with multiple components that make up the meal experience.

Appetizers and entrees pricing

The menu includes categories for appetizers (Garlic Cheese Toast, Bruschetta, Provolone Sticks, Chicken Tenders), entrees (Baked Lasagna, Chicken Parmigiana, Chicken Fettuccine, Garlic Mizithra), and salads. While exact prices remain unavailable online, the restaurant chain has an official allergen information document dated November 2018 available as a PDF on the official website.

Complete meal value

The typical meal structure includes hot bread, minestrone soup or salad, the entrée, and signature spumoni or vanilla ice cream for dessert, along with tea or coffee. The official menu notes that “all entrées at The Old Spaghetti Factory are served with hot bread, minestrone soup or a crisp green salad with a choice of dressing, and our signature spumoni or vanilla ice cream for dessert.”

The catch

The lack of published prices means you’ll need to call ahead or check the Toronto location directly at 416-864-9761 to confirm current pricing. Menu items may vary by location, according to The Old Spaghetti Factory’s official menu.

Does The Old Spaghetti Factory Toronto have a kids menu?

Yes, and it’s notably comprehensive. The official kids meal page states that the children’s menu is available for children 12 and under. This is a broader age range than many restaurants offer, which makes it a practical option for families with older children.

Kids options available

The kids menu includes a choice of entrée, with sides like applesauce (40 Cal) or salad (120-280 Cal), plus milk (120 Cal) or other beverages. Dessert is spumoni (170 Cal) or vanilla ice cream (170 Cal). The official menu page provides these calorie counts for each component.

For younger diners, the kids gluten-free pasta menu offers sauce options including Marinara (300 Cal), Rich Meat (340 Cal), Mizithra Cheese & Browned Butter (610 Cal), and more, according to the official gluten-friendly menu.

Family-friendly features

The Toronto location has highchairs available, as noted on TripAdvisor. The restaurant also serves lunch, dinner, and late night meals, making it flexible for different family schedules. For families with dietary restrictions, the Toronto location has some gluten-free pasta options available, though the range is more limited than at some other locations.

The pattern: families with children up to age 12 get a full meal deal (applesauce or salad, milk, and ice cream) plus gluten-free pasta options. Highchairs seal the deal for toddlers.

What dietary options are on The Old Spaghetti Factory Toronto menu?

The Old Spaghetti Factory offers several dietary accommodations, but they come with important caveats. The restaurant is transparent about the fact that “The Old Spaghetti Factory is not a gluten-free establishment and therefore cross contamination or other errors may occur,” according to their official gluten-friendly page.

Gluten-free choices

The chain’s gluten-sensitive menu offers pasta, salad, ice cream, noodles, and dessert options, as documented by Find Me Gluten Free. Gluten-free items are flagged for identification when brought out. Sausages at The Old Spaghetti Factory are gluten-free, and gluten-free salad dressing options are available.

However, at the Toronto location specifically, gluten-free pasta options are limited to fusilli with approximately three dish choices, according to Find Me Gluten Free’s Toronto listing. The Toronto location charges extra for gluten-free pasta, though the specific upcharge amount is not listed publicly.

For those who can eat gluten-free, the gluten-sensitive house salad with Creamy Pesto or Balsamic Vinaigrette contains 190-210 calories, while gluten-free Alfredo sauce over pasta topped with Romano cheese contains 980 calories, per the official website.

Halal inquiries

Halal certification status has not been confirmed through any official source. Searches across the restaurant’s website, third-party review platforms, and community dining resources did not yield halal certification information. Families with strict halal requirements should contact the Toronto location directly at 416-864-9761 to confirm current ingredient sourcing before visiting.

Why this matters

If you have celiac disease or a severe gluten allergy, the limited Toronto gluten-free options and the lack of a dedicated gluten-free prep area mean you’ll need to weigh whether the trade-off is acceptable. For mild intolerances, the restaurant does provide allergen information through their official PDF document.

Complete Menu Specifications

The following table summarizes key nutritional and menu information from the official website and verified sources. Specific prices are not published online, so we focus on what IS available.

Category Item Details
Appetizers Garlic Cheese Toast Popular starter option
Appetizers Bruschetta Classic tomato-based starter
Appetizers Provolone Sticks Cheese-based appetizer
Appetizers Chicken Tenders Kid-friendly option
Signature Entrees Garlic Mizithra Brown butter and Mizithra cheese over pasta
Entrees Baked Lasagna Classic Italian preparation
Entrees Chicken Parmigiana Breaded chicken with sauce
Entrees Chicken Fettuccine Chicken with cream sauce
Gluten-Free Sauces Marinara 490 Cal (GF pasta)
Gluten-Free Sauces Rich Meat 580 Cal (GF pasta)
Gluten-Free Sauces Clam 750 Cal (GF pasta)
Gluten-Free Sauces Mizithra Cheese 1,120 Cal (GF pasta) — highest calorie
Gluten-Free Sides Italian Sausage 340 Cal — gluten-free
Kids Menu Applesauce 40 Cal
Kids Menu Salad 120-280 Cal
Kids Menu Milk 120 Cal
Dessert Spumoni or Vanilla Ice Cream 170 Cal — included with every meal

The catch: calorie counts are available, but prices are not. For budgeting, the missing price tag is the main obstacle.

What We Know vs. What Remains Unclear

Here’s how the evidence breaks down based on source tier and confidence level.

Confirmed facts

  • Menu includes soup or salad and ice cream with every entrée — verified by The Old Spaghetti Factory
  • Kids menu available for children 12 and under — verified by The Old Spaghetti Factory
  • Garlic Mizithra is a signature dish — mentioned across TripAdvisor and official sources
  • Gluten-free options exist but the restaurant is not certified gluten-free — from The Old Spaghetti Factory official statement
  • Toronto phone number is 416-864-9761 — available across multiple platforms
  • Highchairs available at Toronto location — from TripAdvisor
  • Gluten-free items are flagged for identification when served — from Find Me Gluten Free
  • Sausages are gluten-free — from Find Me Gluten Free
  • Allergen information document available — from official PDF
  • Toronto has limited gluten-free pasta options compared to other locations — from Find Me Gluten Free Toronto listing

What’s still unclear

  • Exact menu prices — not published on any major platform
  • Specific upcharge amount for gluten-free pasta at Toronto
  • Halal certification status — not confirmed through any official source
  • Full gluten-free menu at Toronto location — differs from other locations
  • Whether Toronto has dedicated gluten-free preparation areas
  • Complete list of seasonal or promotional menu items

What Diners Are Saying

All entrées at The Old Spaghetti Factory are served with hot bread, minestrone soup or a crisp green salad with a choice of dressing, and our signature spumoni or vanilla ice cream for dessert.

— The Old Spaghetti Factory (Official Menu Policy)

The Old Spaghetti Factory is not a gluten-free establishment and therefore cross contamination or other errors may occur.

— The Old Spaghetti Factory (Official Gluten-Sensitive Statement)

Be sure to specify modifications when placing your order.

— The Old Spaghetti Factory (Gluten-Sensitive Menu Guidance)

The Old Spaghetti Factory is a popular choice for many travelers seeking generous portions and value, with meals including unlimited bread, soup or salad, and ice cream.

— TripAdvisor (Review Aggregator)

The Old Spaghetti Factory’s Toronto location sits at the waterfront, making it a convenient stop for tourists and locals alike. The restaurant strikes a balance between comfort-food familiarity and family-friendly pricing—though the lack of published prices means calling ahead at 416-864-9761 remains your best bet for budgeting your evening.

Related reading: La Buche Quebec City Menu

Additional sources

oldspaghettifactory.ca, osf.com

Toronto’s casual pasta havens like The Old Spaghetti Factory pair well with trendier Italian spots, including Gio Rana’s Really Really Nice menu, building a cult following downtown.

Don't miss these

Frequently asked questions

Is The Old Spaghetti Factory famous?

Yes, The Old Spaghetti Factory is a well-known American chain with multiple Canadian locations. The Toronto waterfront location has been operating for decades and maintains strong reviews on platforms like TripAdvisor. It’s recognized for generous portions and value-oriented dining.

Is The Old Spaghetti Factory Canadian or American?

The Old Spaghetti Factory is an American chain with locations across the United States and Canada. The Toronto location falls under the Canadian operations but follows the same menu structure as the broader chain.

What is the best pasta dish at The Old Spaghetti Factory?

Garlic Mizithra is widely considered the signature dish. It features browned butter and Mizithra cheese over pasta and has become the dish that most regulars associate with the restaurant. Other popular options include Baked Lasagna and Chicken Parmigiana.

Does The Old Spaghetti Factory Toronto have a kids menu PDF?

There is no dedicated PDF menu for the Toronto location. The official website provides menu information at osf.com/menu, and allergen information is available in a PDF document from November 2018. For specific pricing or menu availability, contacting the Toronto location directly at 416-864-9761 is recommended.

Does The Old Spaghetti Factory Toronto offer halal options?

Halal certification status has not been confirmed through any official source. Searches across the restaurant’s website and third-party platforms did not yield halal certification information. If you require halal-certified options, contact the Toronto location directly to confirm current ingredient sourcing.

What gluten-free options are available at The Old Spaghetti Factory Toronto?

The Toronto location has limited gluten-free pasta options (fusilli only with approximately three dish choices) compared to other locations, according to Find Me Gluten Free. The restaurant charges extra for gluten-free pasta. The official gluten-friendly menu lists multiple sauce options, but these may not all be available at Toronto. Importantly, the restaurant is not a gluten-free establishment and cross-contamination may occur.

What is a must-eat in Toronto for Italian food lovers?

The Old Spaghetti Factory’s Garlic Mizithra is a distinctive option you won’t easily find elsewhere—brown butter and Mizithra cheese is an unusual combination in Toronto’s Italian dining scene. For those seeking variety, the all-inclusive meal format (bread, soup or salad, entrée, ice cream) provides good value compared to other waterfront restaurants.